The European Union’s approach to biofuels in its post-2030 renewable energy framework could have significant consequences for climate emissions, land use and food security, according to a new analysis by Transport & Environment (T&E).
The analysis examines potential policy scenarios as the European Commission prepares to shape the next phase of the Renewable Energy Directive (RED III), which will determine the role of renewable fuels in Europe’s transport sector beyond 2030.
The findings raise concerns about a possible expansion of first-generation biofuels produced from food and feed crops, including the potential impact on agricultural land and greenhouse gas emissions.
Current Policy Could Allow 72% Increase in Crop-Based Biofuels
According to T&E’s modelling, the existing cap under RED III could allow the use of food- and feed-crop-based biofuels in the EU transport energy mix to increase by 72% compared with consumption levels recorded in 2024.
The analysis estimates that emissions associated with first-generation biofuels already reach nearly 43 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (MtCO₂e), when indirect land-use change is taken into account.
This is approximately 23% higher than the emissions from the fossil fuels these biofuels replace, according to the organisation.
Indirect land-use change occurs when agricultural land used to grow crops for biofuel production displaces food or feed production elsewhere, potentially encouraging the conversion of forests, wetlands and other carbon-rich areas into agricultural land.
Such changes can release stored carbon and reduce the overall climate benefits expected from replacing fossil fuels with biofuels.
Three Policy Scenarios Highlight Potential Environmental Risks
T&E modelled different outcomes to examine how changes to the EU’s biofuel policy could influence consumption, land requirements and emissions by 2040.
Under a scenario in which safeguards follow the existing RED III framework and other transport regulations, the volume of food- and feed-crop-based biofuels, land use and associated emissions could potentially double.
The resulting emissions could be equivalent to those produced by more than five million diesel cars.
A more unfavourable scenario would involve harmonising the cap on first-generation biofuels at 7% across EU Member States’ transport sectors. Under this approach, biofuel volumes, land requirements and emissions could almost triple compared with current levels.
The analysis also examines a scenario in which the cap is increased to 10%.
In this case, the organisation estimates that biofuel volumes, land use and emissions could reach four times their current levels by 2040.
Land dedicated to biofuel production could rise to approximately 17.7 million hectares, equivalent to 18% of the EU’s arable land and an area larger than Greece.
Under this scenario, emissions could exceed those associated with the fossil fuels being replaced by 33 MtCO₂e.
These figures are projections based on the policy scenarios modelled by T&E and do not represent confirmed outcomes of the European Commission’s future framework.
Advanced and Waste-Based Biofuels Need Strategic Allocation
The analysis also highlights concerns surrounding the availability and use of advanced and waste-based biofuels.
Unlike conventional biofuels produced from food and feed crops, advanced biofuels can be made using waste materials and other sustainable feedstocks. However, the supply of these resources remains limited.
T&E argues that the road transport sector is currently consuming more of these available feedstocks than it should, given the needs of sectors where direct electrification is more difficult.
The organisation recommends prioritising these fuels for aviation and other transport segments that face greater challenges in transitioning away from conventional fuels.
This approach could help ensure that limited sustainable feedstocks are directed towards applications where alternative low-carbon technologies are less readily available.
Concerns Over Imported Feedstocks and Palm Oil Derivatives
The report also raises concerns about the reliability and sustainability of biofuel imports from countries outside the EU.
Recent cases of fraud in the biofuel supply chain have highlighted the risks associated with relying on third-country exports without sufficiently strong verification and traceability systems.
T&E has called for all palm oil derivatives to be phased out of the biofuel supply chain and for stronger safeguards to ensure that only the most sustainable feedstocks are used.
Effective monitoring and certification would be important for preventing fraud and ensuring that biofuels deliver genuine emissions reductions rather than shifting environmental impacts to agricultural supply chains and other regions.
European Commission Preparing Post-2030 Renewable Energy Framework
The European Commission is currently preparing a renewable energy framework for the decade following 2030, with proposals scheduled for publication by the end of 2026.
The framework is intended to support Europe’s climate objectives, energy security, industrial competitiveness and access to affordable domestic energy.
The existing Renewable Energy Directive establishes a binding target of at least 42.5% renewable energy in the EU’s overall energy mix by 2030, with an ambition to reach 45%.
For transport, Member States are required to achieve either a 29% share of renewable energy or a 14.5% reduction in the greenhouse gas intensity of transport fuels by 2030. The directive also includes a combined sub-target of 5.5% for renewable hydrogen and advanced biofuels.
The Commission’s upcoming framework will determine how renewable energy contributes to the bloc’s longer-term climate and energy priorities.
Balancing Energy Security with Food and Environmental Protection
The debate over biofuels highlights a broader challenge for European policymakers: expanding renewable energy use while ensuring that climate benefits are not undermined by indirect environmental consequences.
Crop-based biofuels can contribute to reducing dependence on fossil fuels, but their expansion may also create competition for agricultural land and food resources.
The findings presented by T&E underline the importance of sustainability safeguards, reliable feedstock certification and prioritising limited advanced biofuel resources for sectors that are difficult to electrify.
As the European Commission develops its post-2030 framework, decisions on biofuel eligibility and limits could influence the future direction of Europe’s transport decarbonisation strategy.
Disclaimer: This report has been editorially prepared using publicly available information and published research. Readers are advised to refer to official European Commission documents and the original research for further details.
